Head and Neck cancERs International cOviD-19 collabOraTion

On 11 March, the World Health Organization (WHO) formally declared the corona virus

disease-19 (COVID-19) outbreak a pandemic. After the first cluster of cases emerged from

Wuhan, in China, at the end of 2019, up today almost 2 million cases of infections from

severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) have been diagnosed across

all five continents in the last few months.By the end of February 2020 COVID-19 had

already hit Europe hard, particularly Italy, with 12462 confirmed cases according to the

Istituto Superiore di Sanità as of March 11th, and 827 deaths. Considering the high

transmissibility and the severe disease occurrence in a fraction of the population,

healthcare systems face a great challenge. The estimated risk of death varies, indeed

from the 12% In China at the peak of the epidemic, to ≈1% in less affected regions

including Europe, USA, Australia, Latin America, Iran, and Canada.COVID-19 morbidity and

mortality have been linked to elderly age and comorbidities, leading to a poorer outcome

from the viral infection in frail patients, more often resulting in hospitalization,

intensive care unit admittance and need for invasive tracheal intubation. Among 2 such

individuals, cancer patients represent a large subgroup at high risk of developing

coronavirus infection and its severe complications. A recent nationwide analysis in China

demonstrated that, of 1590 COVID-19 cases from 575 hospitals, 18 had a history of cancer

(1% vs 0.29% of cancer incidence in the overall Chinese population, respectively), with

lung cancer as the most frequent diagnosis. Patients with cancer were observed to have a

higher risk of severe events compared with patients without cancer (39 vs 8%; p =

0.0003). Moreover, cancer patients who underwent recent chemotherapy or surgery had a

higher risk of clinically severe events than did those not receive treatment. With the

limit of a small sample size, the authors concluded that patients with cancer might have

a higher risk of COVID-19, and poorer outcomes, than individuals without cancer. As a

consequence, they recommended considering an intentional postponement of adjuvant

chemotherapy or elective surgery for stable cancer in endemic areas. Nevertheless, as

subsequently highlighted by other authors, the true incidence of COVID-19 in patients

with cancer would be more informative in assessing whether such patients have an

increased risk (and morbidity) from this viral illness. Furthermore, COVID-19 pandemic

has led to delay in cancer diagnosis and modifications in cancer treatment to limit as

much as possible the number of patients in order to reduce the risks of contamination by

the SARS-Cov-2 virus for both patients and the caregivers. Arduino PG et al reported a

substantial delay in oral cancer diagnosis in north-west Italy due to COVID19 outbreak.

In addition, the management of cancer patients is modified during the COVID-19 pandemic

including delays in surgery, delays and modification of radiation treatment schedule.

Cancer Societies have issued treatment guidelines of cancer patients during COVID-19

which include treatment adjustments the impact of which is currently unknown. In

addition, the coexistence of COVID-19 and cancer may increase the incidence of treatment

complications such as postoperative thrombosis and pulmonary emboli. For COVID-19 +

thyroid cancer patients treated with tyrosine kinase inhibitors, treatment complications

and outcomes are very relevant clinical questions. Furthermore, the limited cancer

patient population described in this first report from the literature, was characterized

by the lack of individuals receiving anticancer immunotherapy. Indeed, only chemotherapy

and surgery were cited among treatments received by patients in the month prior to

developing COVID-19. Maybe, this could simply be due to the casualty of a small sample,

or otherwise, it could suggest that cancer patients receiving immunotherapy are less

prone to develop COVID-19 or to be admitted in hospital due to severe coronavirus

symptoms. Currently, we are aware of the probably higher incidence of misdiagnosed

coronavirus infections compared with that reported and updated every day; it is likely

that a large portion of healthy and young population develop COVID-19 with mild symptoms,

not requiring hospital admittance and thus escaping the laboratory confirmation of the

disease.

Cancer patients undergoing treatment with anti-PD-1/PD-L1 currently used in everyday

practice to treat head and neck carcinoma constitute a growing oncological population.

Their specific susceptibility to bacterial or viral infections has not been investigated.

Considering that immunotherapy with Immune Checkpoint Inhibitors (ICI) is able to restore

the cellular immunocompetence, as it was previously suggested in the context of influenza

infection, the patient undergoing immune checkpoint blockade could be more

immunocompetent than cancer patients undergoing chemotherapy. In the recent weeks, in the

countries heavily affected by the COVID-19 outbreak, such as Italy, scientific

associations recommended the prudential postponing of active cancer treatments,especially

for stable patients not needing urgent interventions. On one hand, this recommendation

could be reasonable for advanced cancer patients receiving chemotherapy, with the risk of

hematological toxicity and of worsening an immunosuppressed status, thus favoring

COVID-19 morbidity. On the other hand, some oncologists are even currently wondering

about the risk of administering ICI in the middle of the COVID-19 outbreak, essentially

due to two major concerns.

The first seems to be represented by the potential overlap between the

coronavirus-related interstitial pneumonia and the possible pneumological toxicity from

anti-PD-1/PD-L1 agents.

Even if lung toxicity is not the most frequent adverse event of ICI, it can be life

threatening.

The overall incidence rate of ICI-related pneumonitis ranges from 2.5-5% with

anti-PD1/PDL1 monotherapy to 7-10% with anti-CTLA-4/anti-PD-1 combination therapy. The

dominant radiological pattern of lung Immune-related Adverse Events (irAEs) is organizing

pneumonia,but ICI-related pneumonitis could exhibit a variety of patterns, also including

nonspecific interstitial pneumonitis. Despite being rarer than other irAEs, pneumonitis

is the most fatal Adverse Event (AE) associated with PD-1/PD-L1 inhibitor therapy,

accounting for 35% of treatment-related toxic deaths. Considering that underlying lung

disease, particularly including interstitial pneumopathy, is considered a risk factor for

ICI-related pneumonitis, it could be reasonable taking into account the risk of treating

patients while they are developing an initial form of COVID-19. The synergy between the

two lung injuries, despite only hypothetical, cannot be surely ruled out. Nevertheless,

such an epidemiological coincidence should not prevent the oncologist from offering a

potentially effective and often well-tolerated treatment even in the middle of the

COVID-19 outbreak, since the duration of the pandemic is still currently unpredictable.

The second concern seems to be represented by a possible negative interference of ICI in

the pathogenesis of COVID-19. Cytokine-release syndrome (CRS) is a phenomenon of immune

hyperactivation typically described in the setting of T cell-engaging immunotherapy,

including Chimeric Antigen Receptor (CAR)-T cell therapy but also anti-PD-1 agents. CRS

is characterized by elevated levels of Interleukin (IL)-6, Interferon (IFN)- γ and other

cytokines, provoking consequences and symptoms related to immune activation, ranging from

fever, malaise and myalgias to severe organ toxicity, lung failure and death. In

parallel, one of the most important mechanisms underlying the deterioration of disease in

COVID-19 is represented by the cytokine storm, leading to acute respiratory distress

syndrome or even multiple organ failure. The cytometric analyses of COVID-19 patients

showed reduced counts of peripheral CD4 and CD8 T cells, while their status was

hyperactivated. In addition, an increased concentration of highly proinflammatory CCR6+

Th17 in CD4 T cells has been reported, and CD8 T cells were found to harbor high

concentrations of cytotoxic granules, suggesting that over activation of T cells tends to

contribute to the severe immune injury of the disease. Moreover, the pathological

findings associated with acute respiratory distress syndrome in COVID-19 showed abundant

interstitial mononuclear inflammatory infiltrate in the lungs, dominated by lymphocytes,

once again implying that the immune hyperactivation mechanisms are at least partially

accountable for COVID-19 severity. Considering these aspects, the hypothesis of a synergy

between ICI mechanisms and COVID-19 pathogenesis, both contributing to a

counter-producing immune hyperactivation, cannot be excluded. In spite of this

fascinating rationale, we should remember that ICI-induced CRS is a quite rare phenomenon

as well as that the cytokine storm is not an early event in the COVID-19 pathogenesis,

indeed characterizing the late phase of its most severe manifestation, occurring in a

minority of patients. It is not likely that cancer patients are still receiving ICI

during this phase of the viral illness. Obviously, in the current pandemic scenario,

careful attention should be dedicated in delaying treatment for those patients presenting

flu-like symptoms at the time of the intended ICI treatment.

Considering this background, we propose a global registry to describe and monitor head

and neck cancer patients with COVID-19; identify factor associated with severe

complications; develop a tailored risk assessment strategy for head and neck cancer

patients; and develop treatment recommendations for head and neck cancer patients.